Sale 930 — United States Stamps
Sale Date — Tuesday, 27 February, 2007
Category — Essays, Proofs and Specimens: Back-of-Book Issues
10c Orange, Special Delivery, Panama-Pacific Small Die Proof on Wove (E3P2a). Large margins, vibrant color, Very Fine and choice, scarce as only 3-5 were produced
1c-50c Brown, Postage Due, Plate Proofs on India (J1P3-J7P3). Matched set of bottom left corner margin blocks of four, each on card and so free from the usual defects which can plague this paper, Very Fine and choice, scarce and desirable set
2c Claret, Postage Due, Plate Proof on Card (J32P4). Block of four, large margins, intense shade and impression, Very Fine
1c-$20.00 Officials, Plate Proofs on India (O1P3-O93P3). Complete set, incl. few pairs (several with imprint) and also 90c Post Office block of four, few small faults as usually found on this fragile paper, Fine-Very Fine, scarce set
$2.00 Green & Brown, State, Atlanta Trial Color Proof (O71TC). Large margins, bright colors, Very Fine and choice
$2.00 Scarlet & Blue, State, Atlanta Trial Color Proof (O71TC). Large margins, bright colors, small pinhole, thin spot at top, otherwise Very Fine
1c Black, Newspaper, Large Die Essay on India (PR81-E1a). On 64 x 74mm card, fresh and Very Fine, scarce essay
1c Newspaper, Trial Color Plate Proofs on India (PR81TC3). Six of the seven Scott-listed colors, large margins, bright colors, usual small defects as found on this fragile paper, Very Fine appearance
2c-$100.00 1895 Newspaper, Large Die Proofs on India (PR102P1-PR113P2). On approximately 151 x 198mm cards with full die sinkage, few with some toned spots, otherwise Very Fine set
(1c) Black, Large Die Essay on Old Ivory Paper, Franklin Carrier (LO1E-E1 -- listed in Scott on white bond paper). Approximately 60 x 50mm with 57 x 50mm die sinkage, unfinished die with lathework impinging on white oval and framelines complete at top and bottom, vertical and horizontal layout lines especially distinct at right, rosettes at lower right, diagonal crease and tiny thin spotONE OF FOUR ORIGINAL 1851 TOPPAN CARPENTER DIE PROOFS IN BLACK, OF WHICH THREE ARE IN PRIVATE HANDS.
Students currently attribute the design of the Franklin Carrier to E. Pitcher. The vignette was engraved by Joseph Ives Pease after a marble bust by Caffieri. The frame is thought to have been the lathework of Asa Spencer, and the letter was by Henry Earle. At the time of production, Henry Saulnier was the siderographer.
The most recent article on Franklin Carrier die essays (Larry Lyons, Penny Post, Oct. 2003) describes three original large die essays in Black, including one in the Miller collection at The New York Public Library (ex Chase) and two in private hands (one ex Johnstone, sold in Siegel Sale 853, lot 2462, for $9,500 hammer). Based on the measurements of the three described by Lyons, it is apparent that this is the fourth recorded example. The paper is Old Ivory, not white bond. It was part of the Falk Finkelburg "reserve" collection, and this could be the first time it has ever been offered at auction.
Ex Slater (pencil note on back "A. B. Slater"). Scott value for LO1-E1 on white bond paper is $10,000.00
(1c) Franklin Carrier, Green Trial Color Plate Proof on India (LO1TC3). Block of four, large margins to clear, radiant color, Very Fine, scarce block, Scott Retail as singles
1c Eagle Carrier, Green Trial Color Plate Proof on India (LO2TC3). Block of four, large margins to just in, rich color, Very Fine, scarce multiple, Scott Retail as singles
American Letter Mail Co., 5c Black, Large Die Proof on India (5L1P1). 47 x 67mm with full die sinkage, fresh and Very Fine, unlisted in Scott , the eagle die was originally engraved by Durand, Perkins & Co. and later incorporated by Rawdon, Wright, Hatch & Edson into the American Letter Mail Co. stamp of 1844 -- similar to an example offered in our 1997 Rarities sale (which showed the die number)
3c Red Centennial, Double Line Under "Postage", Trial Color Proof (Undersander E72Aa). 43 x 43mm, rich color, Very Fine, a sensible space-filling alternative to the rare U220, with 2003 P.S.E. certificate, Undersander value as entire $350.00
Post Office Registry Seal, Deep Blue Trial Color Die Proof on Card With Colored Border (OXF1TC). 110 x 66mm, fresh, Very Fine and choice, surprisingly rare and seldom seen trial color proof
(no value) Deep Red, Test Stamps (TD19, TD23). Two blocks of four with right sheet margin of first, two pairs of second, few trivial imperfections, Fine-Very Fine
(no value) Deep Red, Die Essay on Thick Glazed Card (Brazer 385aE-Ab, Scott TD20P1). 73 x 83mm, ms. "Sample of surface printing from die: done by Bureau E & P 5/20/1910", also with blue "420270" on back, Very Fine, scarce essay
(no value) Deep Red, Test Stamp Proof on Thick Card (Brazer 385aE-Ac, Scott TD20P1). Stamp size and with printed "42039" in blue on back, Very Fine and choice, listed in Brazer as being unique
3c Minerva, Harris Automatic Press Company Offset Essay on Hard White Wove Paper (Brazer 385a-E2a, 385-E2b, Scott TD28, TD29). Horizontal pair of each, large margins, first with natural paper wrinkle, Very Fine, scarce, Harris installed one of their presses in the B.E.P. to demonstrate production of stamps by the offset method, the design was adopted from the 2c 1901 Issue, the presses were not adopted at that time but were used for printing some Revenue stamps, particularly Tax Paids
Toppan, Carpenter & Co., 90c Washington, Schernikow Die Essays (72-E1c/72-E5j). 25, incl. Nos. 72-E1c, 72-E2b, 72-E3b, 72-E5d (13 of the 15 listed colors), 72-E5e three, 72-E5g, 72-E5i, 72-E5j (4 of the 5 listed colors), fresh and Fine-Very Fine, desirable group
